Renée Duvаl is а highly sоught-аfter wardrоbe and cоstume designer specializing in historically accurate European period dress. She is hired by Victor Hale, the producer of a Broadway musical adaptation of The Count of Monte Cristo, set in France between 1815 and the 1830s. Years earlier, when Renée was an unknown designer newly arrived in New York, Victor allowed her to live rent-free in an apartment he owned for six months. Renée has often said she “owes her career” to Victor. On January 1, Victor and Renée have a phone conversation. Victor asks Renée to design and produce all principal costumes for the production. Renée responds, “For you, I’ll do it at $40,000—far below my usual rate—just to repay what you did for me.” Victor agrees. No written contract is signed. Renée begins work immediately, purchasing specialty fabrics imported from Europe and hiring assistants. In March, Victor emails Renée: “Time is absolutely critical! Costumes must be ready for the dress rehearsal on May 1.” Renée replies: “Understood.” In early April, a fire at a textile warehouse destroys a large shipment of rare silk Renée had ordered, and a sudden trade embargo prevents her from obtaining replacement material from her usual supplier. Renée scrambles to find substitutes but insists that authentic materials are essential to the production’s artistic integrity. On May 1, Renée delivers most costumes but fails to provide those for the lead actor and actress. Victor, panicking with opening night less than a week away, purchases original period costumes from a high-end Parisian atelier for $150,000. Victor informs Renée that he is terminating their agreement. Renée is publicly embarrassed by the replacement and asks Victor to issue a press release stating they “parted ways due to artistic differences.” Victor refuses. Renée sues Victor, seeking compensation for her labor and materials already expended. Victor counters that Renée materially breached the agreement and that her failure is not excused. Discuss all claims, defenses, and remedies.